Let me guess. You just finished You Season 2 faster than you could finish a bag of Flamin' Hot Cheetos (sorry, Delilah), and now you're just remembering all the little moments you didn't take the time to appreciate while you binged. Like...haven't you seen Henderson before? And why does Ellie look so familiar?
Welp, the short answer is that these people are actors, so naturally, they're in other projects. LOL. Here's where you've seen everyone from You before.
On the show, Henderson is a comedian with a creepy hidden life. He's portrayed by real-life actor and comedian Chris D'Elia. He's been in a few shows and movies, but if you had Vine, that's definitely where you know him from. His Eminem impression is scarily accurate. You've probably also seen his stand-up routine about drunk girls...and if you haven't, you've def heard one of your friends say, "Do the math!" in reference to it on a night out.
As soon as Ellie (Jenna Ortega) walked onscreen, I literally had to pause the show to figure out where I knew her from. (Please tell me I'm not the only one who refuses to Google things like this.) Jenna played young Jane on Jane The Virgin!
Love's BFF Gabe is played by Charlie Barnett, who you might recognize from Law And Order: SVU and Criminal Intent, Chicago P.D., or Chicago Fire. But more recently, he starred in Russian Doll alongside Natasha Lyonne, and that's probably the reason your brain tricked you into thinking he was actually your best friend too.
Another one of Love's friends, Lucy, is played by Marielle Scott. Remember when she played Shelly Yuhan in Lady Bird?
This article originally appeared on Cosmopolitan.com. Minor edits have been made by the Cosmo.ph editors.