Kylie Jenner is reportedly pregnant (much like everyone else in the Kardashian family), but wait—what if she's already given birth in secret.
Thanks to the re-discovered photos of the beauty entrepreneur looking very pregnant in September, the internet seems convinced that Kylie quietly had her baby and failed to inform the rest of us.
Also shoutout to this person, who is convinced the Kardashians were looking at Kylie and her new baby in their Christmas card:
Not to mention all these enthusiastic theorists:
Before we go theorizing about whether she has or hasn't given birth yet, it would be great to know whether she's actually even pregnant with some form of confirmation from the Keeping Up With The Kardashians family. Can someone put us out of our misery? Will we ever know? Is this just some big April Fool's?
This article originally appeared on MarieClaire.com. Minor edits have been made by the Cosmo.ph editors.